When I was a kid, Peter and the Wolf, narrated by Basil Rathbone, was one of my favorite albums. It was released on 3 78-rpm records and I listened to it so often I practically wore out the groves. A few years ago, I bought the version narrated by Leonard Bernstein, but somehow, it didn't seem the same.
Yesterday, on a hunch, I discovered that the original, Basil Rathbone version was available for download. I compared the two versions and discovered that Bernstein really dumbed-down his version. How sad. Here, without comment are several sentences and phrases from each version.
Rathbone Version
|
Bernstein Version
|
The little bird hopping back
and forth along the bank.
|
The little bird hopping after
her along the shore.
|
Suddenly, something caught
Peter’s eye.
|
All of a sudden, something else
caught Peter’s attention.
|
So stealthfully, she crept
toward him on her velvet paws.
|
…and she slowly crept toward
the bird on her velvet paws.
|
…while the duck quacked angrily
at the cat.
|
…and quacked at the cat with
all her might.
|
The duck quacked excitedly and
splashed her way out of the pond.
|
…and in her excitement, she
jumped right out of the pond.
|
And suddenly, he caught her.
|
And bang, he got her.
|
Presently, he ran into the
house…
|
He ran home…
|
…take care that he doesn’t
catch you.
|
…watch out he doesn’t catch
you.
|
How the bird irritated the
wolf.
|
Oh, how the bird did tease that
wolf.
|
All at once, some hunters came
out of the forest.
|
Just then, Peter saw some
hunters coming out of the woods.
|
Imagine the triumphant
procession.
|
Just imagine the victory
parade.
|
Grand pa-pa shook his head. This is all very well, but what if Peter had
not caught the wolf? What then?
|
Grandfather, of course, was
pretty grumpy about the whole thing.
|
In his haste, the wolf had
swallowed her alive.
|
The wolf, in all his excitement
and hurry, swallowed her alive.
|
No comments:
Post a Comment